Anthony's Pizzeria | American Pizza in East Rockaway, NY

Fresh hand-tossed pizza from Anthony's Pizzeria in East Rockaway

East Rockaway, NY

Hand-Tossed & Neighborhood-Proud

East Rockaway's slice of Long Island since day one - pies, parm, and pasta made the old-school way. Delivered hot to your door.

Order Online

4.5★Avg Rating

217+Reviews

16"Neapolitan Pies

The Anthony's Way

At Anthony's Pizzeria, every pie starts with dough tossed by hand and sauce that neighbors keep asking about. We're proud to be East Rockaway's go-to for classic American comfort - from breaded parmigiana to hearty penne alla vodka to a 16-inch Neapolitan cut into eight slices. Nothing fancy, nothing faked. Just generous portions, fresh ingredients, and the kind of flavor that turns first-timers into regulars. Order it hot and delivered right to your door.

Anthony's 16-inch Neapolitan pizza with melted mozzarella

Straight From The Oven

Our Best Sellers

Parmigiana

Breaded chicken cutlet or veal with sauce & melted mozzarella.

Two large cheese pies with a dozen garlic knots special

Pizza & Garlic Knots Special 🍕

2 large cheese pies & dozen garlic knots. Additional toppings for an extra charge.

Alla Bolognese

Fresh ground beef & peas with tomato sauce & a touch of heavy cream topped with ricotta cheese.

Family Treat box with cheese pie, penne alla vodka, salad and garlic knots

Family Treat ❤️ Date Night Deluxe or Family Treat Box

Large cheese pie, penne alla vodka, house salad, dozen garlic knots. Additional toppings for an extra charge.

16-inch Neapolitan pizza cut into eight slices

Neapolitan 16"

A 16-inch pizza topped with melted mozzarella cheese and a rich tomato sauce, cut into eight slices.

Alla Vodka

Creamy pink sauce sautéed with vodka, imported prosciutto & shallots.

The Neighborhood Speaks

What Folks Are Saying

4.5 ★Based on 217 reviews

Every single thing was absurdly delicious! Granted a majority of my compliments are based solely on the dough they used, but it's just too good to not comment on! Buffalo Chicken 10" crust was beyond my expectations with it being so soft and with the right amount of crunch. Chicken Parm Roll (MOST LOVED ❤️) had that same soft texture, and then chicken was so tasty to mix! Then the Garlic Knots are something else with all that smoothness, and Pepperoni Bites had that same feel and zing, but with the marinara sauce used for everything, it is just outrageous! I was thrown back how good that sauce was! I feel I need to hide it now to make sure I could use it elsewhere. Now my only minor complaint is withOur Specialty Garlic Knot Sliders where it was definitely as scrumptiou and good as the rest, but the chicken I got with mine maybe needed a knife cutting on my part. I'll take full ownership for that flub, but overall, it feels criminal to rate less 6 stars! Seriously phenomenal!

Luis R

Pizza & Wings 🍕. Game Night Combo was a great deal. the wings were amazing their Buffalo flavor was amazing. the food was fresh and the portion was huge. the pizza was so fresh I would definitely order again

Ria E

The best grill chicken I have eaten in Long Island You can taste the grill chicken is well cooked And the buffalo wings are banging also I don't trust pizzerias but this one is official

Steven J

Ready When You Are

8 Centre Avenue, East Rockaway, NY 11518
(516) 593-3440

Delivery Pickup

Order Online

When We're Firing The Oven

Monday: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Tuesday: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Wednesday: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Thursday: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Friday: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Saturday: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Sunday: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM

Good To Know

Questions & Answers

What meals do you serve?

Anthony's Pizzeria serves delicious American cuisine perfect for family dinners, date nights, and casual meals. Our menu features classic favorites like the Parmigiana, a breaded chicken cutlet or veal topped with sauce and melted mozzarella. Pizza lovers can enjoy our 16-inch Neapolitan pizza or our Pizza & Garlic Knots Special with two large cheese pies. We also offer hearty pasta dishes like Alla Bolognese and our popular Family Treat box, complete with a large cheese pie, penne alla vodka, house salad, and garlic knots.

Do you offer delivery or takeout?

Yes, we offer both delivery and pickup. Order conveniently by calling us directly.

Where are you located?

Anthony's Pizzeria is located at 8 Centre Ave, East Rockaway, NY 11518, USA.

What areas do you serve?

We proudly serve East Rockaway and surrounding areas including Lynbrook, Rockville Centre, Baldwin, Oceanside, Valley Stream, Hewlett, Woodmere, Malverne, Island Park, and Long Beach, NY.

Order Online